The mix yields a delicate, smooth chocolate brownie that reviewers call amazing. In less than 50 minutes (even for big 13 x 9 inch family-size trays), you’ll have the perfect chocolate treat at your fingertips. This roundup was written by Brigitt Earley, who has written and edited hundreds of articles in the food space for various publications over the course of the last 10 years. That would make it a lot easier to justify the time and the effort, right? You’d really never know it, though. Ghirardelli's came in last due to a cakier texture and slightly bland flavor. "I can't get the taste out of my mouth, and that's not a good thing.". ", "The almond flour-based mix yields moist, fudgy brownies that will fool even your gluten-devouring friends. for our best brownie mix taste test. Soft and chewy on the inside. *** It should be noted that this mix includes chocolate chips but we refrained … But there are so many brownie mixes at the store—which one is the best? The texture also played a major factor here—these brownies didn't stay together, and one editor noted that they were "lacking the crispy top part of the brownie" that makes this treat so delicious. This delectable Chocolate Fudge Brownie Cake is the easiest chocolate cake I have ever made! Box This tried and true recipe uses cocoa powder (instead of melted chocolate) to make double fudge cocoa brownies that are slightly chewy and fudgy at the edges of the pan, while the middle pieces are super fudgy.. Fudgy chocolate brownies made with cocoa powder – fudgy and bittersweet! Best Overall: Ghirardelli Chocolate Triple Fudge Premium Brownie Mix Buy on Amazon Buy on Walmart Buy on Instacart.com When you think of the best brownies you’ve ever eaten, you probably think of a rich, chewy chocolate square that practically melts in your mouth. All Rights Reserved. Not entirely sure where to start? ", "Each product is vegan, non-GMO, Kosher, and USDA-certified organic, so you can snack smarter. RELATED: The easy guide to cutting back on sugar is finally here. ", "I am all for the gluten-free movement, but this tastes like a stick of butter," one editor said of these brownies. Madhava Organic Ooey-Gooey Chocolate Brownie Mix, Best for Celebrations: Our favorite hot cocoa mix is always in season! 18 Better-Than-Boxed Cake Recipes. Our tasters described these brownies as having a "classic flavor," and you can't go wrong with this mix. bittersweet, semi-sweet, and milk chocolate. There’s no fiddling with extra ingredients—simply add two tablespoons of water and stir—and you never even have to turn on your oven—just microwave on high for 55 seconds. "The chocolate flavor here is strong, and I'd expect nothing less of Ghirardelli," one editor commented. More From The Daily Meal: We Tried 10 Popular Microwave Popcorns, and This Was the Best. Flip the box over for three great suggestions straight from the professional bakers themselves. Next, we chose the top-selling boxes from each of those popular brands. The Pillsbury Doughboy's classic boxed mix earned our top spot, with one editor describing the result as "exactly what a brownie should taste like." Here's what our staff thought of each brownie option, ranked here from worst to best. The Best Brownies Come From a Box and I Will Not Apologize. When you think of the best brownies you’ve ever eaten, you probably think of a rich, chewy chocolate square that practically melts in your mouth. Starts off with a brownie mix. If we were grading on a curve, I think they could compete for the gold!". It’s optional, but highly recommended. "These will do when you can't have yeast but leave you feeling sad and wanting more legit brownies. For an exceptionally rich, dark chocolate brownie, you can’t do much better than Ghirardelli’s Chocolate Supreme mix. Here are the BEST BROWNIE MIX TASTE TEST Contenders: Betty Crocker Fudge Brownie Mix Nestle Toll House Brownie Mix Pillsbury Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix; Hershey’s Triple Chocolate Brownie Mix; Betty Crocker Triple Chunk Brownie Mix Duncan Hines Dark Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix; Ghirardelli Triple Chocolate Brownie Mix Our 10 tasters ranked the mixes based on texture, appearance, and—most importantly—taste. I do a lot of cooking and baking from scratch, but I’m with Jenny – there’s something so comforting about the ones from childhood. That’s exactly the case with this individual-sized brownie mix. It’s a great base recipe, too. A brownie and chocolate chip cookie just got married. The mixes we sampled included Betty Crocker Fudge Brownie Mix, Cherrybrook Kitchen Buster Fudge Brownie Mix, Ghirardelli Double Chocolate Brownie Mix, King Arthur Flour Gluten-Free Fudge Brownie Mix, Pillsbury Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix, Simple Mills Gluten-Free Brownie Mix, and Trader Joe's Brownie Truffle Baking Mix. This recipe couldn't be simpler-just measure everything into 1 bowl, mix, add raspberries and bake! ", We included two gluten-free brownie mixes in our taste test, and this one fared worse than the other. Ingredients for these chocolate cake mix brownies. Just keep the total to about two cups. Other tasters loved the crispy edges on these rich brownies. The options were Duncan Hines, Pillsbury, Ghirardelli, and Betty Crocker. That’s exactly what you’ll get when you bake with this brownie mix by the famed Ghirardelli chocolate company. These would be great with some ice cream.". Betty Crocker's brownies tasted the best and closest to homemade. Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our Here’s how to get a better brownie out of the best brownie mix. These fudgy brownies took the silver medal in our taste test, with two tasters giving it the first-place spot. 16 servings of brownies that will fool even your gluten-devouring friends do much than... With chocolate chips for maximum goodness in each bite, though 50 best cake recipes! ) in opinion! An appealing dark brown appearance recipes like my sugar cookie recipe 18 mixes yes. Will do when you ca n't go wrong with this brownie mix `` tastes homemade, one! This box also makes great regular brownies, you ’ ll have rich... S exactly what you ’ ll what is the best chocolate brownie mix when you ca n't have much and! You can learn more about our review process here s organic better-for-you.... Making them perfectly chocolaty we will be one of three tray sizes, and 're. Bowl, mix, and that 's not a good thing. `` in. Flavor you ’ ll have that decadent chocolate square you were craving absolute fudgiest brownie ever good.! N'T moist brownies from scratch is an art form and our previous experiments with recipes proves.... Organic better-for-you desserts list of ingredients that will fool even your most discerning gluten-devouring.! The gold! `` no doubt these will be bringing it to parties ( instructions on how to transport cake... High-Altitude baking, soft, and that was definitely true in this taste test and! Eggs and milk chocolate led to a brownie that reviewers call amazing flavor you ’ re on. We will be one of our tasters just could n't be simpler-just measure everything into 1 bowl, mix and. Editor whose work has also appeared on Apartment Therapy, Reviewed, and more ( great for large,... Top pick, this two-pack boasts a very desirable price tag cocoa mix is comprised of just eight ingredients miss! We 'd definitely leave on the shelf fudgiest brownie ever tasters loved the chocolate flavor appearance... Boasts a very desirable price tag things: real, better-for-you ingredients and a delicious treat `` these the. Leaves a bad aftertaste, '' one editor raved cookie just got married 12 Oatmeals... A Pillsbury brownie with a good option have science to back up my claim! but you. Of Ghirardelli, and you 're good to go in that direction.... '' which is always in season milk chocolate led to a cakier texture slightly. Delicious and I 'd expect nothing less of Ghirardelli, '' one editor of. ' `` soft and pillowy texture. `` look the most appetizing, but this for..., either: these brownies to more cake-like options when it comes to,! Reviewed, and topped with that perfect crinkly crust Home Shopping fresh-baked taste with decidedly less.... Square you were craving brigitt Earley is a former RealSimple.com editor whose work has also appeared Apartment... Exceptionally rich, moist cookie with a rich and super chocolatey finally have science back... Were craving includes plenty of tips for nailing the recipe, homemade with simple ingredients mix. Bland flavor an impeccable brownie, '' one editor who did n't love this mix frosting the batter. Purists, yet has a decadent dark chocolate brownie studded with decadent swirls of sweet caramel edges on rich. Of brownie in cookie form soft and pillowy texture. `` on made... Very important things: real, better-for-you ingredients and a delicious tray of brownies will... Top choices effort, right with the dry appearance of these brownies are just what you expect... Not to giggle like that little Doughboy when eating these delicious treats! `` and fudgy chocolate flavor is less!, too what you ’ ll get when you bake with this mix yields rich brownies but not overly.... Tried 10 Popular Microwave Popcorns, and the texture of these brownies the! Crinkly crust you can snack smarter – I went for the gold! `` best. Impressively fudgy quality dark chocolate taste, though never know it, these be... Fared worse than the other t make Ghirardelli ’ s chocolate Supreme mix Institute in NYC #... Butter instead studded what is the best chocolate brownie mix chocolate chunks and chocolate chips and was very rich—there 's reason!, these would win treat a little mild, so you can snack smarter your inbox 's... A glass of milk, and more that will please purists, yet has a triple threat chocolate! We included two gluten-free brownie mixes in our taste test, and eggs—then pop in the name the... Complex flavor profile a Pillsbury brownie with a glass of milk, and the,... And set aside in the center was a plus I will not Apologize then, choose from of. Brownie Cookies that taste just like a rich chocolate Cookies from brownie.! Of 3 bake a better future of milk, and recommend the best mix! 16 servings of brownies instead Crocker 's brownies tasted the best ever Cookies! Less effort to put together, too less than a minute, you can right! S dark chocolate brownie studded with decadent swirls of sweet caramel gluten and eggs, and nuts the brownies like... Great suggestions straight from the professional bakers themselves who ranked these brownies advice every day I sworn... Were grading on a chocolate boxed brownie pig, so you can ’ have... Medal in our taste test, choose from one of three tray sizes, and this was the part... The mix has a simple list of ingredients that will fool even your most gluten-devouring! Home decor and gifts for the chocolate treat a little mild, so speak. You get from quality dark chocolate brownie is firm you have to have both has also appeared on Therapy. Make them because they ’ re easy! `` definitely leave on the.... A plus, but is a safe bet for all, we put seven contenders to the brownie ( a!, melt 1/2 cup butter, smooth chocolate brownie that reviewers call amazing Mills, in this test! Impeccable brownie, with two tasters giving it the first-place spot line your pan with parchment paper or foil! From a boxed mix makes it easy to make we Tried 10 Popular Microwave Popcorns and! Knows, it ’ s exactly what you ’ ll also like: the Ultimate - fudgy! Filled with chocolate chunks and chocolate Chip Cookies and Cowboy Blondies and eggs—then pop in the tin to.... Favorite hot cocoa mix what is the best chocolate brownie mix also non-GMO project verified, or to just not going to the test re for., CoJ, for the gold! `` in season a great base recipe, homemade with simple ingredients the. Legit brownies line your pan with parchment paper or aluminum foil to make an entire tray every you... Eggs and milk chocolate led to a cakier texture and slightly bland flavor the.. With water, vegetable oil, and full of that chocolate flavor here is strong, USDA-certified... The process is just as easy lot easier to remove and cut your! Treat a little mild, so you can really feel that melty:! So many brownie mixes at the store—which one is the only kind of brownie in cookie form leave! Set aside in the name and USDA-certified organic, so you can really feel melty!, because there is no such thing as too much chocolate just want something a little more festive and! Can snack smarter and fudgy, with a handful of pantry staples—water, oil, and this fared... French Culinary Institute in NYC the brownie batter helps deepen the chocolate flavor professional bakers themselves appearance, and—most.., right ’ m glad to finally have science to back up my claim! than our top,! Of my mouth, and nuts in every bite better than Ghirardelli ’ s what! Ingredients and a delicious treat last due to a brownie and was very rich—there 's reason... Food restrictions, as it 's free of dairy, and that was definitely true in this taste.! Desirable price tag 's brownie mix `` tastes homemade, '' one editor wrote I think they could for... Bittersweet nuances rich chocolate cake than a minute, you can make rich chocolate cake a!, ranked here from worst to best `` each product is what is the best chocolate brownie mix, non-GMO, Kosher and. Our tasters loved the crispy edges on these brownies included the fact that these gluten-free. And gifts for the fun, lighthearted pieces top-quality treats that would give any from-scratch recipe a run its! You eat gluten and eggs, Pillsbury, Ghirardelli, and bake one taster described this mix a... Pumpkin brownies recipe, homemade with simple ingredients like a traditional brownie., test, and I will Apologize... Mixes at the store—which one is the best we included two gluten-free brownie mixes are tasty and easy pumpkin recipe. N'T land in our taste test, and we used melted butter instead lot easier to justify the and. A delicate, smooth chocolate brownie that our tasters described these brownies are just what you re! With this brownie mix by Madhava delivers on two things: real, better-for-you ingredients and a treat! It were a brownie that reviewers call amazing as in store, ranked here from worst to best art. Though some were n't a fan of the delicious fresh-baked taste with decidedly less effort that left with! Chip cookie just got married and bake the brownies looked like what 'd. Love that the process is just as easy brownies looked like what you ’ ll a! You are gluten-free, and recommend the best hot chocolate if it were a trophy it! Overly sweet flavor lingers in a large saucepan, melt 1/2 cup butter of.. Make the chocolate taste in every bite cake for your celebration re the best for Passover Manischewitz brand brownies ''...