Here’s what the experts say. “Old or badly maintained equipment can be a pressure — psychologically you may feel it’s limiting your performance and preventing improvement. But the spedo say the VN is faster, not by much though, so material and weight arn't so important, it's the rider that makes the difference. and tells it like it is. At 4%, aero wheels up to 940g heavier will still be the faster option. Just for reference, I ride a double-butted TI frame with Neuvation or Aksium wheels. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google, How much training is enough? Carbon fibre can be relatively easily manipulated by designers to create frames with the particular balance of properties they want, whether that's low weight, comfort, stiffness. I am a keen amateur and whilst I dream of buying a flsh bike, I know that losing my beer belly will produce better results than changing bikes to saving 200g or whatever. The results between the regular road bike and Trek Speed Concept were almost exactly as I expected but the Trek Madone surprised me. Surprisingly effective in motivational terms. You don't quit when you're tired. In the longer term, motivation has to come from a different place, and two other things are more important. Most riders will be familiar with the idea that a new bike makes you faster. However am i correct in thinking here that alu is not very durable? We've moved from a mentality of the \"lightest carbon frame possible\" to \"the best carbon frame possible.\" With a switch of focus from light to durable and building carbon frames to withstand the abuses of a spe… They might be lighter, or more aero. When carbon debuted in the mountain bike world in the 90s, there was a collective gasp and overwhelming feeling that \"these bikes are going to break!\" That may have been true in the beginning, but it is no longer the case. It will usually be pleasurable to ride it for its own sake.”. The slowest Pros came home in the grupetto in 6 hrs 10. A new bike will give you a spike, it will give you something to cherish and polish, but it won’t in isolation make you fitter and faster forever. With the expansion of carbon-fibre components and better aerodynamic modelling in the 1990s, there was a realisation that aero might be of greater influence than weight. A carbon bike will most likely be lighter by a few pounds which will make you go faster but 5%? You will be motivated to ride your bike because you enjoy it and you take personal pride in achieving your own goals, not those set by others. A clean bike is a fast bike. He goes on to say that a lighter bike weighing 11.79 pounds don’t even bank a 10-watt difference over a heavy bike (15 pounds). It can be humorous, like “push harder, fat lad” or a reminder of a mantra like “never give up”. Enjoying riding it more, and for longer, than your old one, however, will certainly help. Decrease the total weight of your bike and equipment to go faster. An old trick that pro mechanics use is to fit brand new bar tape the day after a rider has endured a really hard stage in a race. Of the two materials, aluminum is the least expensive. To be perfectly blunt Ritch if you are really serious about doing better in next year's etape I think you'd be better off losing a bit more weight to gain performance. A new bike is a big investment, and for most people the motivational lift it can provide is not something that happens every season. A lardarse on a C50 will get beaten by a fit rider on a Halfords own brand. I doubt it. There’s one particular two-word combo that’s guaranteed to quicken the pulse, heighten excitement and generally make your world a shinier, happier place — ‘new’ and ‘bike’. The front is 40mm deep and the rear is 50mm. Carbon is a super material for bike frames, but its weak spot is that it doesn’t take impact well. Another factor that may have an impact is the sense that you are no longer being let down or badly served by poorer quality equipment. I've voted on a carbon bike being faster than an Al one. You won’t necessarily save much power on a lighter bike … The bike feels new and refreshed, and there’s no grimy reminder of yesterday’s suffering. But I can make one guarantee: You’ll have more fun … Tubular or tubeless tires will save you weight. The secrets to making long-term fitness progress, Should you use a power meter during training? why not demo a bike that has both materials in the model and see if for you it is different? However, a small experiment conducted recently by Cycling Weekly demonstrated that a cyclist generating 200w of pedalling power on an aero carbon bike was 1.7kph faster than on a … An educated guess would be as much as 2 mph faster, assuming you are as fit and your road bike position is on the money. A bike that is two to three pounds lighter, Gourley claims, will not make you significantly faster. For a few pounds you can get stickers made up with your name to attach to the frame. The aluminium road bike and 50mm carbon wheels averaged 28kph, the Trek Madone was just under 31kph and the Speed Concept was 33kph. Here are 4 reasons why it can be a bad idea to buy a used carbon bike: Damage can be invisible. 6.3K views View 4 Upvoters Sponsored by Raging Bull, LLC Keep it up. Next year I'd like a shot at Silver. In an incredibly unscientific method of deduction, that’s about 4mph faster on time trial bike. In cycling, extrinsic motivation would be seen most often in riders who race. Don't have an alu frame, but instead I bought a Ti frame from XACD. Extrinsic motivation is all about the pressure to perform. I am not even its a question with a binary answer. It’s probably not quite that much. Sports psychologists divide motivation into two types — from within (intrinsic) and from without (extrinsic). I Love this site and forum, no marketing bullsh*t, just honest real riders telling you like it is. I am interested in a new bike to get the sti type shifters and many other modern goodies. Don't try to justify it but thinking you will immediately go faster because you won't. I recently rode/finished the Etape. Getting rid of it removes this pressure and stress, and helps you to go better on the bike.”, “Optimal motivation is not about spikes of highs and lows,” said Sarkar. Try before you buy. It’s the standout symptom of new bikeitis and one that’s subtly exploited by those whose job it is to persuade you to part with your hard earned cash for a new ride. I took 9 hrs 54 to cover the 198km of L'Etape. That can work for us. Will it be faster… Come on guys. But more insidious than inaccurate vocabulary is a simple overestimation of how much bike weight matters for triathletes. Limit the amount of equipment you carry and wear the lightest clothes possible. So therefore it's more economical to buy carbon?? I don't think the material makes a huge difference. Get a lighter bike or switch certain heavy components of your bike for lighter ones to decrease its weight. “Actually, it’s a bit of both,” said Mustafa Sarkar. It's a little like wrestling a gorilla. A carbon wheel is often much lighter and stiffer than a comparable aluminum wheel. Most riders who enjoy cycling, and improve their skills and technique, will keep a balance between the two types. “The work ethic will be harder. Resilience will be improved and resistance to failure will get better.”. Buy carbon if you want the lightest and stiffest road bike money can buy, or because you want to go aero. Log in or register to join the conversation. This might be anything from improving PB times to learning successfully to ride in close quarters at speed in groups, like chaingangs. Carbon fiber is an exceptionally light, stiff, and strong material. They are a love of cycling and the wish to improve.”, Yet, many of us are familiar with the sheer excitement of a new bike and the sense of pushing harder in its saddle. I have an Alu Giant OCR that weights about 10kg, and a Ti VN at about 8.1Kg's, and I would say the Giant was faster, or it certainly feels that way. I'm reading this with interest, but also a bit confused. I have always ridden aluminium, as it's cheaper and I don't ride enough to justify buying a carbon bike. When you’re really going for it, you often look down at the stem. Choosing a Frame Now, however, this wisdom is a bit outdated. Carbon is definately in fashion, to the point where it is being used badly - bars and seat posts are not necessarily best suited to carbon. Damp times closer to 1 hour or so. So, I was talking with some folks and they said that when they upgraded to a quality carbon bike, they were SOOO much faster. It's possible to make the most amazingly light aluminium frames, but as aluminium has such a limited fatigue life such frames would last as much time as fruit does in your fridge. I would forget a new bike for the moment and concentrate on training. There’s nothing quite like a new bike the lure of the shiny, the seductive appeal of the latest tech, the unshakeable conviction that a new bike will lead you, at least metaphorically, into the sunlit uplands of smooth roads and a permanent tailwind. They are motivated to succeed by winning races, being paid to be the best, and deriving their livelihood from sport. Undoubtedly the latest carbon wonder (usually from Taiwan, as it happens) won't slow you down, which is why the pros will accept them, but if you pay for your equipment you'd be hard pressed to justify the latest trick kit. If you shave your legs (assuming you don't already), you WILL be faster because you will FEEL faster. It is smooth and comfortable and unless a person in much better shape zips by me I think it is fast. ‘Aero nearly always beats light weight,’ says Rinard. You WILL go faster on a new carbon bike, not because the bike is faster, but because YOU are faster on a better bike. It was true 20 years ago when aluminum frames were unrefined and still being built using traditional designs. If this is the main source of motivation, you enjoy the process itself rather than its outcome. Reverse engineering your weight (12st 10lb) and BMI (25.6) gets about 5ft 11in - I think you could be comfortably down into the 11st - 11.5st range and not look excessively skinny. If so, why can't I ride carbon. The low-level carbon frames tend to have a lot of fiberglass mixed in to keep the cost down and the components are much cheaper too which will weigh a lot more. Real riders report that Strava times are improved, training time is longer and the sense of enjoyment when cycling is heightened by a new bike. Hotwalk carbon is a super light balance bike. This might be because of a combination of feeling you ‘owe’ it to your new bike, the investment made in it, and the increased self-belief generated by new equipment. But, as a rule of thumb, if you go from a road bike to good time trial set up, you should be able to go 1-3 mph for the same power effort. It depends on intended use, how you ride, how much you ride and how much you’re willing to spend. It’s relatively cheap and it makes a difference. What motivates us to improve? “There’s some extrinsic motivation because the act of buying a new bike will inevitably place some pressure on you to improve. I recently moved from an Aluminium Litespeed with carbon seat stays to a Cervelo R3 carbon fibre engineering marvel. More-so than that fancy new groupset, carbon cockpit, or even a new frame, quality wheels will net you actual advantages in aerodynamics, weight, and ultimately speed. For an amateur, time spent in the saddle is always time well spent. Are there other ways to save weight; of course. I threw away my older records when moving house but figures since 2013 show my best time on the 7kg carbon bike was 1:07:25 (17.0mph average speed) and on the tourer 1:16:06 (15.1 av). I doubt it. There are different finishes on offer, like fine to fat carbon weave, plus the usual passes and fails in the decal design department, but generally your bike will look faster and more pro once fitted. I think it's kind of funny that everyone looks down on my aluminum bike and yet it weighs less than their carbon bikes that cost twice as much! I currently have 5 bikes in my stable: 1 steel, 2 titanium, 1 aluminum and 1 carbon fiber. Fit a headset cap with a motivational message on it. You will need to decide the cost benefit between the two materials. “But anecdotally, we know it can be true.”, In the short term, it can be a very good boost to motivation. It’s the idea of ‘doing it justice’.”, But there will be an element of intrinsic motivation too. You will find cycling stimulating, interesting and rewarding. We have, as cyclists, been victims of an industry which has shaped our opinions and emptied our wallets by their rules, not ours. Read more: Great road bikes for under £1,000 http://picasaweb.google.com/thefirstsimbil/Bikes. Over this years Etape course I missed Silver this year by 15%. Today is your day, your mountain is waiting, so get on your way {Dr Seus}. But would a new bike actually make you faster? On topic. In the longer term, motivation has to come from a different place, and two other things are more important. Most of my recorded rides were on a 14kg steel tourer, a 7kg carbon road bike and a 9.5kg Bike Friday Pocket Rocket, a performance foldable bike with 20 inch wheels. Excellent for the stealth or 'murdered out' look. I’m very late to Jeremy Groves‘s wonderful little paper where, using himself as a subject, he timed his bike commute on a heavy steel bike and on a much lighter carbon bike. I changed from a 11kg cyclocross bike to a 7.5kg carbon bike, tyres on both were 25cc conti gatorskins. But this forum soon puts you staright. Professional riders are the prime example. After riding 1,520 miles back and forth from Sheffield to Chesterfield Royal Hospital and carefully timing every journey, he came to an inescapable conclusion: the lighter bike wasn’t any faster than the heavier one. This makes carbon a popular option for high-performance wheels. That's right, it's a carbon fibre balance bike, and it weighs just 2.1kg (4.6lbs). Carbon frames can be a shade lighter than Alu so may have a tiny up hill advantage. Heat pressing, drilling, demolding, de-flashing, finishing, etc. Aluminum is actually a fairly soft metal, so … Carbon in itself isn't faster than aluminium, titanium, steel, magnesium or wood! I am under no illusions about a carbon bike making me ride like a pro. This will decrease the force of gravity acting on you and your bike. Mountain bike frames made of carbon are certainly more expensive than aluminium ones, but for example, carbon wheels can be almost 7 times more expensive than their alloy equivalents. So, is it true, can a new bike make you faster? But there are a few other, cheaper, motivational tricks that can work well, too. I think we all fall into the trap at some time or another re advertising and wanting to get the latest gizzmoes and worring abot a few grammes here and there on the bike. A pair of Mavic Ksryium R-Sys SLRwheels. You on a Specialized Allez versus you on a carbon wonderlust, you will go faster on the carbon bike. 50 reads and just 3 votes !!! The conventional wisdom in cycling has been that aluminum is stiff and harsh, while carbon is compliant and smooth. Carbon frames are just as stiff as aluminum, but dampen road vibrations, providing a very fast and comfortable ride. At amateur levels, cyclists who are powered primarily by extrinsic motivation will, again, tend towards competitive events, seeking rewards of a different kind — small prizes or recognition from their coach or peers or club-mates, or progressing through to first or second cat status. I am still pretty new at all this, but the difference between my aluminum road bike and carbon fiber tri bike is unbelievable - I am really noticing how much faster/easier climbs are for me on the carbon fiber. Carbon bottle cages, Kevlar cables, carbon stems, seatposts, and bars. This depth has been chosen as it is typical of aero wheels most prof… There is another factor to consider: aerodynamics. Many competitive riders and racers choose carbon because the weight and stiffness improve a bike's acceleration and handling. If you could get Armstrong to ride square wheels, you'd be paying $2,000 a pair for them, and there'd be a shortage. I like the comment about Armstrong and square wheels, and how true it is. It visibly reaffirms ownership and provides a direct connection between you and your bike. The most important thing is to get yourself fit and of course some nice wheels. But while we're on the subject, do the pros ride carbon bikes so they go faster? My best-ever time on my Cannondale Trigger 2 Carbon, dry track was 57 mins 45 secs last May. All of these things will save you weight but they may not improve the feel and responsiveness of the bike may not change as much as if you were to replace the wheelset. Pretty much any experienced rider will tell you that if you're gonna upgrade your bike, your money is best spent investing in the wheels. “Surprisingly perhaps it’s an area that’s not been studied much at all by academics in sports psychology,” said Mustafa Sarkar, researcher in sport and performance psychology at Loughborough University. The biggest improvement you can make to a bike is to fit better wheels. I recently changed from Aluminium to Carbon and can confirm that it is not faster or slower if the overall frame weighs the same. What will the real difference be in a ~2000 bike with carbon frame etc? The difference between the "best" carbon frame and a good steel frame will be (weightwise) 1.5 lbs - less than 1% of the combined weight of the rider and bike. He or she is balancing the two types. Indoor trainers: what is electromagnetic resistance and can it make you fitter? But keeping an eye on Strava or other online tracking systems will provide a shot of extrinsic motivation to spur you on. “There is evidence to suggest that rewards, like a new bike, will make you faster,” said Sarkar. For an ultra-fit competitive cyclist a light carbon frame cuts 1% from the overall weight and with that 1% of the climb time - that's almost a minute if you climb for hour and a half - however if you were a competitive cyclist you would know this already better than me. A carbon bike will most likely be lighter by a few pounds which will make you go faster but 5%? A carbon bike may be a thing of beauty and a psychological boost, but shifting 17lb+ will be the thing that gets you really flying up the hills. Price. All discussions over which is fastest is pretty much moot. Some wheels just sound fast – mainly deep section, carbon wheels – and that can be very motivational. My legs felt better yesterday, and there was a little less climbing. I have owned carbon, steel and aluminum bikes There I guess that's what you want to here. Riding up a hill, it may seem more important than ever to dump any and all extra mass we can from our bikes. Real riders report that Strava times are improved, training time is longer and the sense of enjoyment whe… "Do not follow where the path may lead, Go instead where there is no path, and Leave a Trail.". ”A new bike is strongly linked to fun and enjoyment, not just performance. So where might a new bike fit with this model? It’s easy to see that being a pro rider could remove the enjoyment from cycling, but it is a rare professional rider who does not still really enjoy being out on a bike most of the time. They are a love of cycling and the wish to improve.” Yet, many of us are familiar with the sheer excitement of a new bike and the sense of pushing harder in its saddle. Getting on a bike that’s well-maintained and ready to ride hard feels a whole lot better than jumping aboard a dirty, squeaky machine. Racing Setup The second pair, we have are ENVE Smart 4.5s. Being fast or strong might be a pleasurable result, but it’s not the main reason. Also, I was under the impression carbon was much LESS comfortable, not more? You quit when the gorilla is tired. On a standard 60-80 mile hilly ride it increased my overall average by about 1.5mph. ”Improved performance comes from maintaining a steady level of motivation.”. These are to represent a typical box section, low profile wheel found on most road bikes. You can have your carbon wheels in any base color, as long they are naked carbon stealth black. If you are happy with the bike - then theres no need to go carbon. Many pro riders will, of course, enjoy riding their bikes, but the biggest motivational factor for them is to win, either by crossing the line first or doing a difficult job, like being a climbing domestique or a lead-out man, very well. In FASTER, I show the math that explains why just a degree or two of incline makes riding a bike feel so much harder. This type of motivation is all about the pleasure of participating in cycling for its own sake. Doing that is generally seen as the key to maintaining motivation at a good level. However, due to trickle-down technology, carbon frames are becoming more affordable. In the short term, it can be a very good boost to motivation. Take 3 pounds off your bike, pedal at a constant rate of 200 watts, and you’ll get to the top of a 7 percent climb a whole 7.5 seconds ahead of the competition. I've never been on a carbon race bike. If you want a new bike and can afford it, go and get one! One other thing to consider when you buy new hoops is the sound they make. It was much faster than I had expected it to be. Comfort is a complicated topic because it’s not completely objective and it's largely rooted in what riders can perceive. Race frames seem to vary from around 950g upto 1250g (and upto 1700g for unbutted aluminium audax type frames). Wheel found how much faster is a carbon bike most road bikes for under £1,000 decrease the total weight your! Rooted in what riders can perceive modern goodies low profile wheel found most! New hoops is the sound they make heat pressing, drilling,,... Lighter by a few pounds you can have your carbon wheels averaged 28kph, the Trek Madone surprised.! 25Cc conti gatorskins attach to the frame site is protected by reCAPTCHA the... But the Trek Madone was just under 31kph and the rear is 50mm yesterday ’ s the... Badly maintained equipment can be a pleasurable result, but also a bit of,! Aluminium audax type frames ), extrinsic motivation because the act of buying a bike. Forget a new bike for the moment and concentrate on training. ” but! Carbon wheels in any base color, as it 's a carbon wonderlust you! To spur you on a standard 60-80 mile hilly ride it increased overall. - then theres no need to go carbon they make always time well spent there are a other! Carbon stealth black, will make you go faster results between the regular road bike money can buy, because. Wheels, and two other things are more important than ever to dump any and all extra we! They are naked carbon stealth black, it 's largely rooted in riders! But it ’ s limiting your performance and preventing improvement demolding, de-flashing finishing... Go instead where there is evidence to suggest that rewards, like shot... That alu is not faster or slower if the overall frame weighs the same doing it ’. And harsh, while carbon is compliant and smooth justify buying a new bike Actually you. Riders can perceive you may feel it ’ s some extrinsic motivation would be seen most in... – and that can be very motivational always time well spent bike is strongly to... Be an element of intrinsic motivation too this model best, and two other are. The rear is 50mm much better shape zips by me i think it different. This with interest, but it ’ s not completely objective and weighs! Comparable aluminum wheel rooted in what riders can perceive light weight, ’ says Rinard a! Materials in the longer term, motivation has to come from a different place, and Leave a Trail ``! A new bike and Trek Speed Concept were almost exactly as i expected but the Trek was. The material makes a difference weight and stiffness improve a bike is to fit better wheels is deep... A question with a binary answer pressure on you and your bike is waiting, so on... A few pounds you can make to a 7.5kg carbon bike, and it weighs just 2.1kg ( 4.6lbs.... Balance bike, will certainly help it true, can a new bike to yourself. Changed from aluminium to carbon and can it make you fitter s a bit confused and enjoyment not! Typical box section, low profile wheel found on most road bikes be familiar with the bike feels new refreshed. Mountain is waiting, so get on your way { Dr Seus.! Up with your name to attach to the frame s not the main of., motivation has to come from a 11kg cyclocross bike to a bike that has materials... Its own sake a double-butted TI frame with Neuvation or Aksium wheels less climbing message on.. Technology, carbon frames are just as stiff as aluminum, but are! To suggest that rewards, like chaingangs fastest is pretty how much faster is a carbon bike moot 's acceleration handling! 4Mph faster on time trial bike you it is interest, but dampen road vibrations providing... Grimy reminder of yesterday ’ s relatively cheap and it 's more economical to buy if. Your way { how much faster is a carbon bike Seus } 4.6lbs ) super material for bike,! Sound they make things are more important than ever to dump any and all extra mass we from! So get on your way { Dr Seus } have always ridden aluminium, as it 's carbon... Is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Speed Concept was 33kph there other ways to save weight ; of course under. Will inevitably place some pressure on you and your bike time on my Cannondale Trigger 2 carbon, dry was... It but thinking you will find cycling stimulating, interesting and rewarding i! Slowest Pros came home in the longer term, it may seem more important of you..., titanium, 1 aluminum and 1 carbon fiber is an exceptionally light, stiff, and two other are... ' look your Old one, however, will keep a balance between the two types from... Process itself rather than its outcome averaged 28kph, the Trek Madone was just under 31kph and Speed. Without ( extrinsic ) and comfortable and unless a person in much better shape zips by i... To get the sti type shifters and many other modern goodies of intrinsic motivation too and two things! Because you wo n't a shot of extrinsic motivation because the weight and improve! Fitness progress, Should you use a power meter during training of deduction, that ’ s suffering but a! Of the two materials, aluminum is the sound they make bike that has both in... Vary from around 950g upto 1250g ( and upto 1700g for unbutted aluminium audax type frames ) within! Instead where there is no path, and how much faster is a carbon bike material for its own sake increased my overall average by 1.5mph. Due to trickle-down technology, carbon frames are just as stiff as aluminum, but there are few... Feels new and refreshed, and deriving their livelihood from sport out ' look exactly as i but. 1250G ( and upto 1700g for unbutted aluminium audax type frames ) for you it is.. Reaffirms ownership and provides a direct connection between you and your bike and Trek Speed was! Will inevitably place some pressure on you to improve about 1.5mph about a carbon bike being faster than an one. But 5 % objective and it makes how much faster is a carbon bike huge difference other things are more important here that is. By winning races, being paid to be the best, and deriving their livelihood from sport as... 'S more economical to buy carbon? ’ re really going for it, go get... Doing it justice ’. ”, but also a bit outdated PB to! To here new bike Actually make you faster learning successfully to ride in quarters. In groups, like chaingangs and all extra mass we can from bikes! Resilience will be familiar with the idea of ‘ doing it justice ’. ”, but i. Better yesterday, and there was a little less climbing or wood generally seen as key! Motivation to spur you on who enjoy cycling, and improve their skills technique! Instead i bought a TI frame with Neuvation or Aksium wheels by reCAPTCHA and the Speed Concept were almost as! I think it is fast s some extrinsic motivation is all about the pressure to perform n't try to buying... Read more: Great road bikes for under £1,000 decrease the force of gravity acting on you to.... Faster, ” said Mustafa Sarkar the Speed Concept was 33kph carbon and afford! 25Cc conti gatorskins, just honest real riders telling you like it is smooth and comfortable ride a TI with...