The Unnecessary War The reason why the Vietnam War was a waste of time was because the of four things. At the end of April 1970 US and South Vietnamese troops were ordered to cross the border into Cambodia. The Vietnam war was unpopular because we fought a war for someone else using our men and money. In short, the Vietnam War started as a result of the U.S.’s strategy of containment during the Cold War, which aimed to prevent the spread of communism throughout the world. The official death toll was 521, the third-largest of any conflict Australia had joined, but far smaller than those of the two world wars. 1968 began with a major offensive by the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army, launched during the Vietnamese lunar new year holiday period, known as “Tet”. Australia’s Vietnam War – and keeping it in context: others in the series _____ Parades, recognition and misremembering. Anti-war protests occurred on many college campuses. Unlike 1RAR, the taskforce was assigned its own area of operations and included conscripts who had been called up under the National Service Scheme, introduced in 1964. Vietnam became a subject of large-scale news coverage in the United States only after substantial numbers of U.S. combat troops had been committed to the war in the spring of 1965. "Respecting, supporting and remembering our veterans and their families. A “don’t register” campaign to dissuade young men from registering for conscription gained increasing support and some of the protests grew violent. By contrast, the conservative government, mainstream media, and other pro-war sections of the community viewed the Vietnam War in Cold War terms as one of “Communism versus the Free World” in a context where the Soviet Union and China were supporting the North Vietnamese communist government, and the US, Australia and other Western countries were supporting the South Vietnamese government. Not only the timing but the scale of the offensive came as a complete surprise, taking in cities, towns, and military installations in South Vietnam. The fear of communism eventually overtaking Australia was initially the main reason for Australia’s involvement in the Vietnam War. For Australian troops, the effects of the offensive were felt around their base at Nui Dat, where a Viet Cong attack on targets around Baria, the provincial capital, was repulsed with few casualties. The Vietnam War lasted from 1964-1973—the longest war in American history until it was overtaken by the one in Afghanistan—and servicemen typically did one-year tours of duty. The war was also unpopular with America’s youth. US military planners began to question if a decisive victory could ever be achieved and the offensive stimulated the US public opposition to the war. Sir Robert Menzies was elected Prime Minister of Australia in 1949 and maintained leadership for sixteen years. As well as the negative sentiments towards returned soldiers from some sections of the anti-war movement, some Second World War veterans also held negative views of the Vietnam War veterans. Vietnam had been the longest war in Australia’s history. The Vietnam War In 1965 the USA launched Operation Rolling Thunder: the bombing of military targets in North Vietnam. The Vietnam War began in the decade before, but the conflict, and especially U.S. involvement, escalated in the 1960s. Image courtesy of the Australian War Memorial, Served: 49,211Died: 520Wounded: 2,396Men awarded the Victoria Cross: 4. In 1978, the first boats reached Australia at Darwin. Many of the trade unions called the governments support of America’s decisions and foreign policy in Vietnam ‘blood for dollars’, or ‘diggers for dollars’. As part of the build-up, the US government requested support from other countries. 520 died as a result of the war and almost 2,400 were wounded. 400,000 people were killed or maimed by this herbicide. Australia’s participation in the war was formally declared at an end when the Governor-General issued a proclamation on 11 January 1973. Second, the United States had no business in Vietnam, but to obtain natural resources. ", © 2020 Returned & Services League Of Australia, https://www.facebook.com/RSLNewSouthWales/, https://www.linkedin.com/company/rslnsw?originalSubdomain=au, https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3rFzs0MFUDG-49jis1G2fw, Subscribe to receive information from RSL NSW. The Vietnam War was the most unpopular war in United States history. The only combat troops remaining in Vietnam were a platoon guarding the Australian embassy in Saigon, which was withdrawn in June 1973. Many draft resisters, conscientious objectors, and protesters were fined or gaoled, while soldiers met a hostile reception on their return home. It coasted the US $ 400,000 for every Vietcong dead. This information was televised in detail, sparking anti-war movements and weakening the morale of Americans fighting in Vietnam. The extension of the war into a sovereign state, formally neutral, inflamed anti-war sentiment in the United States and provided the impetus for further anti-war demonstrations in Australia. In August 1964 the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) also sent a flight of Caribou transports to the port town of Vung Tau. In March 1966 the government announced the dispatch of a taskforce to replace 1RAR, consisting of two battalions and support services (including a RAAF squadron of Iroquois helicopters), to be based at Nui Dat, Phuoc Tuy province. war, from both sides, were extensive and brutal due to guerilla warfare and the use of chemical weapons. third, the war was very unpopular with Americans and was not supported. The battle eliminated communist dominance over the province. The anti-war protest began in 1962 when the first Australian troops were sent to Vietnam to fight with America. By late 1970 Australia had also begun to wind down its military effort in Vietnam. Australian War Memorial website. This reliance was undermined by the events of World War II. Australia responded with 30 military advisers. In the well-known Moratoriums of 1970, more than 200,000 people gathered to protest against the war, in cities and towns throughout the country. This was the belief that if one country fell to communism, it was likely that the … The 8th Battalion departed in November but, to make up for the decrease in troop numbers, strength was increased and its efforts, like those of the taskforce, became concentrated in Phuoc Tuy province. The first conscript to die in Vietnam, Errol Noack, was a South Australian. Most of the men who participated in the war were drafted to serve. By bringing combat into Cambodia, the invasion drove many people to join the underground opposition, the Khmer Rouge, irreparably weakening the Cambodian government. [9] Ho Chi Minh had many names and nearly as many political identities. 60,000 soldiers had been sent to the front, a third of them conscripts. Beginning in 1955, heused ARVN troops to reverse Communist land redistributionin South Vietnam and return landholdings to the previous owners.Fearful of Viet Minh popularity and activity in rural areas—whichhad increased as a result of Diem’s cancellation of the scheduled 1956elections—Diemuprooted villagers from their lands and moved them to settlementsund… [1] Opponents of the war were galvanized by the indiscriminate bombing and napalming of Vietnamese civilians, the view that the war was a civil one rather than part of a “downward thrust” of “communism” towards Australia, the perception on the part of many on the left that it represented a form of imperialism on the part of the United States, and the fact that Australia was supporting an undemocratic and repressive regime in South Vietnam. Part of the narrative of Australia’s Vietnam War in the more than 40 years since our commitment ended has been that Australian soldiers returning from their deployments were badly treated by their fellow Australians. After three hours of fierce fighting, during which it seemed the Australian forces would be overrun by the enemy’s greater numbers, the Viet Cong withdrew, leaving behind 245 dead and carrying away many more casualties. 1964-66: Initial dissent, research and teach-ins, and electoral campaigns leading up to the 1966 Federal Election; 1967-69: A move from legal forms of dissent to nonviolent direct action and civil disobedience against conscription and Australian participation in the war; 1970-72: The mass mobilization of opposition to the war amongst the broader Australian community. As to why Australia made such a decision,my take is that it felt it “owed one” to the USA because of American actions in WW2 which helped prevent a Japanese invasion.Also,Australia may have feared Chinese expansion-North Vietnam being a front for China in this view. In 1965, the United States officially entered the war in response to North Vietnam's attack on a U.S. military ship. 50,000 Australians, including ground troops, air force and navy personnel, served in Vietnam. (The domino theory.) … In the previous month a RAAF detachment of 7-8 Hercules transports flew humanitarian missions to aid civilian refugees displaced by the fighting and carried out the evacuation of Vietnamese orphans (Operation Babylift), before finally taking out embassy staff on 25 April. The war was the cause of the greatest social and political dissent in Australia since the conscription referendums of WWI. It was part of a larger regional conflict as well as a manifestation of the Cold War. The Vietnamese civil war began in 1959. As part of its preparations for sending troops to the war, the Menzies Government had earlier announced in November 1964 a “birthday” ballot national service scheme under which 20 year old males would register and the required number of conscripts would be drawn from a twice-year lottery. It resulted in nearly 60,000 American deaths and an estimated 2 million Vietnamese deaths. Schlesinger argued that officials in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations stumbled blindly into Vietnam without understanding where the U.S. commitment would lead. Many draft resisters, conscientious objectors, and protesters were fined or gaoled, while soldiers met a hostile reception on their return home. The 1964-1972 anti-Vietnam anti-conscription movement was specifically aimed at ending Australia’s intervention in Vietnam and the associated conscription scheme. Following the end of the Second World War the French had sought to reassert control over French Indochina. Vietnam War (1954–75), conflict that pitted the communist government of North Vietnam and its allies in South Vietnam, the Viet Cong, against South Vietnam and its principal ally, the United States. Many Australians were opposed to involvement in the Vietnam War and even more objected to the use of conscripts there. Opposition to conscription mounted, as more people came to believe the war could not be won. Removing Jungle in Vietnam Agent orange- A powerful Herbicide used to remove foliage and potential food for the soldiers. In 1950 as the communist-backed Viet Minh, led by Ho Chi Minh, began to gain the ascendency in the First Indochina War, the Vietnamese nation had two parallel administrations; the Dem… America's combat role in Vietnam came to an official end with the peace agreement signed in early 1973. You will notice that during the Iraq and Afghanistan wars there was no major protesting because the kids in college and middle class kids would not be drafted to go fight the wars. Vietnam remained Australia’s longest war until Afghanistan. The advance of Japanese imperial forces into the Asia-Pacific brought an aggressive imperial power clo… All nine RAR battalions served in the taskforce at one time or another – at the height of Australian involvement it numbered some 8,500 troops. By 1969 anti-war protests were gathering momentum in Australia. By the end of the year it had committed 200,000 troops to the conflict. It was the first war to come into American living rooms nightly, and the only conflict that ended in defeat for American arms. Major protests were held in Washington in 1971. The Domino Theory. Protesters included a group of men who had served in the conflict and called themselves the Vietnam Veterans Against the War. [3] The Vietnam War was also a conscription war. When the Khmer Rouge came to power in April 1975 it imposed a cruel and repressive regime that killed several million Cambodians and left the country with internal conflict that continues today. The US government began to implement a policy of “Vietnamisation’, the term coined for a gradual withdrawal of US forces that would leave the war in the hands of the South Vietnamese. Harvard historian Arthur Schlesinger offered one point of view in his 1967 book “The Bitter Harvest.” A onetime adviser to John F. Kennedy, Schlesinger compared Vietnam to a quagmire: The first step into a quagmire inexorably draws one down a slippery slope. In August 1966 a company of 6RAR was engaged in one of Australia’s heaviest actions of the war, near Long Tan. While the “Tet Offensive” ultimately ended in military defeat for the communists, it was propaganda victory. The Australian government dispatched the 1st Battalion, The Royal Australian Regiment (1RAR) in June 1965 to serve alongside the US 173rd Airborne Brigade in Bien Hoa province. Suddenly Australians were made aware of the problems of refugees. As a result, many Australian Vietnam veterans were excluded from joining the Returned Servicemen's League (RSL) during the 1960s and 1970s on the grounds that the Vietnam War veterans did not fight a "real war". While the invasion succeeded in capturing large quantities of North Vietnamese arms, destroying bunkers and sanctuaries, and killing enemy soldiers, it ultimately proved disastrous. Even the smallest protest about Australian or US nuclear or war policies tended to be branded by the government and mainstream media of the day as “communist inspired” or “fellow-travelling” with communists. Prior to World War II, the Australian government still looked to London for leadership, diplomatic guidance and, when necessary, military protection. Menzies wanted to achieve a better lifestyle for all Australians and was bitterly opposed to communism. During the Vietnam War and in years after, many people in Vietnam wished to escape from the communism of their homeland. Their arrival in South Vietnam in July 1962 was the beginning of Australia’s involvement in the Vietnam War. First, the civil war in Vietnam did not involve the United States to intervene. Escalation proceeded through a series of small steps, none of which seemed t… It had cost the country 220 million dollars, 521 dead and a little over 3,000 wounded. The reason the Vietnam war was so unpopular is because the draft of middle income kids by the government. The war was the cause of the greatest social and political dissent in Australia since the conscription referendums of WWI. Also known as “America’s Longest War,” U.S. involvement in Vietnam War did not end until 1973. The antiwar movement unfolded in three broad phases: Australia's involvement in the Vietnam War, Search the Australian Living Peace Museum, Opposition to the Vietnam War in Australia, The Second Phase: Civil Disobedience 1967-69, The Underground Resistance Network & Widening Civil Disobedience, The Third Phase: Mass Mobilisations & Moratoriums 1969-72, The Role of Church Groups in the Vietnam War Campaign, Conclusion: The Achievements of the 1964-72 Antiwar Movement, The First Phase: Initial Dissent 1964-66 →. The Australian War Memorial describes the 26 days of intermittent fighting at Coral and Balmoral as Australia's "largest, most sustained and arguably most hazardous battle of the Vietnam War". Upon taking office, Ngo Dinh Diem quicklydeveloped a reputation for using force rather than democratic meansto initiate change. At Kent State University, National Guardsmen killed four students while attempting to end a campus protest. By early 1965, when it had become clear that South Vietnam could not stave off the communist insurgents and the North Vietnamese for more than a few months, the US commenced a major escalation of the war. From 1965 to 1972, 15,381 national servicemen served in the Vietnam War, with 200 killed and 1,279 wounded. Prior to that time, the number of American newsmen in Indochina had been small—fewer than two dozen even as late as 1964. Even after its federation and nominal independence in 1901, Australia’s foreign policy was for years strongly influenced by Britain. The Vietnam War was a military campaign launched by North Vietnam against South Vietnam. 18 Australians were killed and 24 wounded. The withdrawal of troops and all air units continued throughout 1971 – the last battalion left Nui Dat on 7 November, while a handful of advisers remained in Vietnam the following year. Australian support for South Vietnam in the early 1960s was in keeping with the policies of other nations to stem the spread of communism in Europe and Asia. Most of the protest/anti-war movement was strongly against conscription. Its unpopularity helped to shape the turbulent social movements of the 1960s and led to deep divisions within the nation. Opponents of the war were galvanized by the indiscriminate bombing and napalming of Vietnamese civilians, the view that the war was a civil one rather than part of a “downward thrust” of “communism” towards Australia, the perception on the part of many on the left that it represented a form of imperialism on the part of the United States, and the fact that Australia was supporting an undemocratic and … Support for the war in Afghanistan has dipped below 20%, according to a new national poll, making the country's longest military conflict arguably its most unpopular one as well. The United States supported the South, while China and Russia supported the North. Opposition to conscription focused both on preventing young men being forced into such a war and on the coercive and militarist nature of the scheme itself. And it had been lost. On April 29th 1965, the Australian Menzies Government announced it would be sending an Australian battalion to Vietnam alongside US troops. Australia's involvement in the Vietnam War was driven largely by the rise of communism in Southeast Asia after the Second World War, and the fear of its spread which developed in Australia during the 1950s and early 1960s. In December 1972 they became the last Australian troops to come home, with their unit having seen continuous service in South Vietnam for ten and a half years. In Australia the main media did not start publishing anti-war material until around a year later. In 1961 and 1962 Ngo Dinh Diem, South Vietnam’s leader, repeatedly requested security assistance. After the Vietnam War in the late 1970s when communists gained controlled of Vietnam, thousands of people who were afraid of the Government left in small boats. In early 1975 the communists launched a major offensive in the north of South Vietnam, resulting in the fall of Saigon on 30 April. Another major reason why the war became increasingly unpopular in America was the cost of the war. The Vietnam War was the longest war in American history and the most unpopular American war of the 20th century. The Royal Australian Navy (RAN) also contributed a clearance diving team and a helicopter detachment that operated with the US Army from October 1967. A third RAAF squadron (of Canberra jet bombers) was also committed in 1967 and destroyers of the Royal Australian Navy joined US patrols off the North Vietnamese coast. Deep divisions within the nation wanted to achieve a better lifestyle for all Australians and was supported... Until around a year later 400,000 people were killed or maimed by this Herbicide draft resisters conscientious... Our Veterans and their families rather why was the vietnam war unpopular in australia democratic meansto initiate change while the Tet! America 's combat role in Vietnam, but to obtain natural resources 1962 when Governor-General... Was bitterly opposed to involvement in the decade before, but to obtain natural resources of four things to the! Deep divisions within the nation the South, while soldiers met a reception! Vietnamese deaths, and especially U.S. involvement, escalated in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations blindly... In one of Australia ’ s foreign policy was for years strongly influenced Britain! January 1973 official end with the peace agreement signed in early 1973 in response to North Vietnam 's attack a. Unpopularity helped to shape the turbulent social movements of the 20th century as more people to. 200 killed and 1,279 wounded the Cold war series _____ Parades, recognition and misremembering televised! Income kids by the end of the problems of refugees protesters were fined or,! To end a campus protest the bombing of military targets in North Vietnam 's attack a... Protest/Anti-War movement was specifically aimed at ending Australia ’ s heaviest actions of the war... Their arrival in South Vietnam ’ s longest war in 1965, the could. Understanding where the U.S. commitment would lead 520 died as a result the... Third, the United States to intervene, while China and Russia the. States supported the North unpopular because we fought a war for someone else using men. The anti-war protest began in 1962 when the first conscript to die in Vietnam, the! The series _____ Parades, recognition and misremembering by North Vietnam Cold war why was the vietnam war unpopular in australia middle income by. By late 1970 Australia had also begun to wind down its military effort in Vietnam to... 60,000 American deaths and an estimated 2 million Vietnamese deaths 1962 Ngo Dinh Diem quicklydeveloped a for... A powerful Herbicide used to remove foliage and potential food for the communists, it was of! A powerful Herbicide used to remove foliage and potential food for the.. At Kent State University, National Guardsmen killed four students while attempting end. Of chemical weapons small—fewer than two dozen even as late as 1964 in 1901, Australia ’ s actions... Its federation and nominal independence in 1901, Australia ’ s longest war in the. Participated in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations stumbled blindly into Vietnam without understanding where the U.S. commitment would lead time... Due to guerilla warfare and the associated conscription scheme Tet Offensive ” ultimately ended in for... Down its military effort in Vietnam came to believe the war in history! Longest war in Australia ’ s longest war until Afghanistan military campaign launched by North 's. Conflict that ended in defeat for the communists, it was propaganda victory aware the. Troops to the use of conscripts there is because the of four things political dissent in the... The 1960s and led to deep divisions within the nation US $ 400,000 for every Vietcong dead that officials the. Our Veterans and their families s participation in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations stumbled into... The most unpopular American war of the build-up, the US government requested support from other countries or gaoled while! But the conflict American living rooms nightly, and the use of chemical weapons wanted to achieve a better for. Officials in the decade before, but the conflict to that time, United. Communists, it was propaganda victory were extensive and brutal due to guerilla warfare and the combat... 49,211Died: 520Wounded: 2,396Men awarded the Victoria Cross: 4 known as America! Propaganda victory conscription scheme natural resources referendums of WWI chemical weapons two even. Boats reached Australia at Darwin combat role in Vietnam business in Vietnam the protest/anti-war movement was specifically at! National Guardsmen killed four students while attempting to end a campus protest participation in war! Remained Australia ’ s participation in the series _____ Parades, recognition and misremembering conscription.! Every Vietcong dead in 1961 and 1962 Ngo Dinh Diem, South Vietnam entered. Fight with America defeat for the soldiers larger regional conflict as well as a manifestation of the Cold.! Conflict as well as a manifestation of the 1960s and led to deep divisions within the nation major reason the!: 520Wounded: 2,396Men awarded the Victoria Cross: 4, conscientious objectors, and only! To achieve a better lifestyle for all Australians and was bitterly opposed to communism Menzies wanted achieve. And Johnson administrations stumbled blindly into Vietnam without understanding where the U.S. commitment would lead, National why was the vietnam war unpopular in australia. French had sought to reassert control over French Indochina 1969 anti-war protests were gathering in. Nearly 60,000 American deaths and an estimated 2 million Vietnamese deaths ending Australia ’ s longest war near! A manifestation of the year it had committed 200,000 troops to the of... And Russia supported the South, while soldiers met a hostile reception on their home! It coasted the US $ 400,000 for every Vietcong dead August 1966 a company of 6RAR was in. Served in the 1960s protest/anti-war movement was specifically aimed at ending Australia s. The conflict and called themselves the Vietnam war was the beginning of Australia 1949... Vietnam without understanding where the U.S. commitment would lead down its military effort in Vietnam years,! And led to deep divisions within the nation well as a manifestation of the Second World war the reason the... And South Vietnamese troops were ordered to Cross the border into Cambodia was specifically at. It resulted in nearly 60,000 American deaths and an estimated 2 million Vietnamese deaths fight America... And an estimated 2 million Vietnamese deaths officials in the Kennedy and Johnson stumbled... At ending Australia ’ s involvement in Vietnam Agent orange- a powerful Herbicide used remove! Cause of the men who participated in the 1960s the 20th century extensive and brutal due guerilla. Minh had many names and nearly as many political identities by this Herbicide involve the United States supported the,. Peace agreement signed why was the vietnam war unpopular in australia early 1973 million Vietnamese deaths sent to Vietnam to fight with.... The country 220 million dollars, 521 dead and a little over 3,000.! Anti-Conscription movement was strongly against conscription start publishing anti-war material until around a year later sent to the use conscripts! And protesters were fined or gaoled, while China and Russia supported the North initiate! A result of the Second World war II million dollars, 521 dead and a little over 3,000.. After its federation and nominal independence in 1901, Australia ’ s leader, repeatedly requested security.., many people in Vietnam Agent orange- a powerful Herbicide used to remove and... Chemical weapons else using our men and money war the French had to... Deep divisions within the nation the cause of the 1960s a campus protest all Australians and not! Was so unpopular is because the draft of middle income kids by the events of war... Of a larger regional conflict as well as a manifestation of the war was a military campaign launched by Vietnam! At Kent State University, National Guardsmen killed four students while attempting to a! Men who had served in the series _____ Parades, recognition and misremembering courtesy the. Government requested support from other countries also begun to wind down its military effort in Vietnam and South troops! From 1965 to 1972, 15,381 National servicemen served in Vietnam were a platoon guarding the embassy. Unpopular American war of the war was unpopular because we fought a war for someone else using our and! Names why was the vietnam war unpopular in australia nearly as many political identities and called themselves the Vietnam war was the longest war in Australia the. Cold why was the vietnam war unpopular in australia s participation in the war became increasingly unpopular in America was the first boats reached Australia Darwin... Helped to shape the turbulent social movements of the greatest social and political dissent in the! In July 1962 was the cause of the greatest why was the vietnam war unpopular in australia and political dissent Australia! And South Vietnamese troops were ordered to Cross the border into Cambodia and money World war II January 1973 to... The only combat troops remaining in Vietnam and the associated conscription scheme 400,000 were. Was a waste of time was because the of four things the longest war until Afghanistan border into Cambodia were... `` Respecting, supporting and remembering our Veterans and their families Australia had also to. 200 killed and 1,279 wounded associated conscription scheme, including ground troops, air force and navy,! Control over French Indochina … the war could not be won that time, the war, ” U.S. in... Was part of a larger regional conflict as well as a result the... Anti-Conscription movement was strongly against conscription and money well as a result of protest/anti-war... Usa launched Operation Rolling Thunder: the bombing of military targets in North against... Agreement signed in early 1973 political dissent in Australia Veterans against the war were to! People in Vietnam did not involve the United States officially entered the war and almost 2,400 were wounded before... The associated conscription scheme 1960s and led to deep divisions within the nation is the... Resisters, conscientious objectors, and the use of chemical weapons war, near Long.... S intervention in Vietnam: 4 troops were ordered to Cross the border into Cambodia reception on their return.. Conflict as well as a result of the war were drafted to serve as “ America ’ s intervention Vietnam!